The mysterious fairy foresters was a name that was whispered among the kids in my elementary school. It regarded a group of kids whoโd grown close after a specific summer camp eight years ago.
I grew up in a small town, nestled between a giant, sprawling forest. In many a class during elementary school, weโd set out on brief excursions into the forest to learn about the various trees, forest animals, and the local folklore. The culmination of these excursions was an event that came to be known as the fairy forest. Some teachers at our school had gotten together and organized an event during summer break. At the edge of the forest, theyโd set up a little camping ground, all centered on local folklore. I still remember the sign propped up in a tree, designating the area below as the fairy forest. Tents had been propped up, decorations were sprouting from all the trees, and various games, treasure hunts, and raffles had been prepared to the delight of us kids.
The moment my parents dropped me off, I was head over heels for the place. What I loved the most about it was the mystery surrounding it. While I recognized Mrs. Mรผller, our homeroom teacher whoโd dressed up as a witch, the rest of the adults had gone all out. They were wearing ominous, even scary-looking, costumes and masks, trying their best to hide their faces and voices so we wouldnโt recognize them. It was at this camp, the fairy forest, that the mysterious fairy foresters were born.
While bonds between kids form fast, I still remember the strange little group that crowded together from day two onwards. They hung out during breakfast and lunch, all joined in the same activities, and seemed inseparable. This strange bond, however, continued to last long after the fairy forest was over.
For months, this strange group persisted, giving off the air of a secret society. Before long, someone crowned them the mysterious fairy foresters, and soon tales and rumors about the group spread. Some kids said they talked in their own weird language, so no one could overhear their conversations. Others said they met up in the forest at night, practicing dark magic and strange rituals. Most of us, however, were sure that something mustโve happened between them during the fairy forest. Their change in behavior supported these rumors. Each member of the mysterious fairy foresters was behaving differently. Kids whoโd been loud and energetic had become quiet, even distant.
โMaybe they found something weird in the forest, some sort of artifact or secret treasure,โ one of my friends, Erik, blurted out one day.
โYouโre just saying this because of that stupid movie you watched the other day!โ another one, Johannes, chimed in.
โNuh-uh! I saw them out there, they were all glowing and stuff, and there was this thing in front of them andโโ
โLiar! Youโre making it all up!โ
As the two of them argued back and forth, I saw my best friend Tom. He was shuffling around, opening his mouth to say something before he closed it again.
โWhatโs the matter with you?โ I asked, poking him between the ribs.
โOuch!โ he cursed before he mumbled a โnothing.โ
Thatโs when I knew it was definitely not nothing. I pestered him about it the entire day, and on our way home, he finally relented.
โI saw something that day,โ he said in a conspiratorial voice.
โSaw what?โ
โThat first day of the fairy forest. Do you remember that teacher in the rabbit costume?โ
โOh yeah, no, wait, I donโt. Mrs. Mรผller was a witch, and that big bear had to have been the principal. Mr. Richter was the wolf, and Mrs. Lehmann was that bird thing. No, I donโt remember a rabbit.โ
He nodded but was quiet.
โAre you sure about it?โ
โYeah, I saw it! I was at the archery range, shooting arrows and pretending to be Indians with some other kids, when I heard someone call out to us from nearby.
โWhen I looked over, I saw this guy in a rabbit costume telling us we were going on a treasure hunt to find forest secrets. But Iโd been on that stupid treasure hunt with Mr. Richter at noon, remember?โ
โYeah, it fucking sucked,โ I blurted out. Then I instantly covered my mouth, looking around, to make sure no one had heard me curse like that.
โSo I stayed, but some others joined in, and then a few more kids went with him as well. I thought nothing about it and everyone was back at dinner time.โ
โBut?โ
โIt was them, Daniel!โ
โThem?โ
โThe mysterious fairy foresters! Jan, Melanie, Robbie, all of them! They went with this teacher in the rabbit costume, and ever since then, theyโve all been hanging out together!โ
โI knew it. They mustโve found something really cool, and thatโs why they are all friends now!โ
โBut what about that teacher? He was so weird, and no one else has seen anyone dressed up as a rabbit,โ he mumbled in a low voice.
โIt was probably Mr. Richter or Mrs. Lehmann. Donโt you remember they changed costumes on the last day, too?โ
Tom gave me a curt nod, but I could tell that he wasnโt convinced.
Over the course of the next months, the mysterious fairy foresters persisted, but eventually, their little group drifted apart. Whatever magic or secret had held them together for so long seemed to have dissipated. Before long, nothing but stories and old rumors remained of the little group. As the years passed and we moved on from elementary school to middle school, the name had become nothing but a little inside joke between me and Tom. I was sure the name as well as our memories of the fairy forest would vanish all together. At least, thatโs what I thought.
It was during our town fair that I should learn just how much more there was to the incident Tom had witnessed so many years ago. Our yearly fair is the biggest event in town. Everyone, no matter if they are kids, teenagers, adults, or old people, gets together to dance, drink, and have fun. As a kid, I loved all the different stalls and rides. My favorite were the lottery stall and the shooting gallery where Iโd often spend my entire allowance in an hour or two. As a teenager, however, I learned of a different part of the town fair. The evening and the night. It was all about dancing, getting drunk, and, if you were lucky, making out. I was sitting together with some of my friends in the beer tent having a blast when a girl walked up to us.
โDaniel?โ she asked, poking me.
All of my friends turned to me, and I could see the girl blush before she took a deep breath.
โYou know Isabel from class 9B, right?โ
I nodded. โYeah, why?โ
โSheโs waiting outside by the shooting gallery.โ
With that, the girl turned around and hurried away. I sat there, staring after her. Why the hell was she telling me that and why right now? I turned back to my friends and took a deep sip from my beer. They were all staring at me.
โWhat?โ I asked after Iโd put my glass back down.
โWhy the hell are you sitting here, you idiot?โ Tom asked me.
โWhat do you mean?โ
โOh my god, dude, sheโs interested in you! Go talk to her! Now!โ
When I didnโt get up right away, he pushed me off the bench.
โJust go!โ
And so I went. Needless to say, I was more than nervous. I knew Isabel. We werenโt friends or anything, but weโd talked occasionally, and I had to admit, I liked her a little. Or more than a little, I thought, when I saw her by the shooting gallery. When she noticed me, she smiled. It made my heart race. I tried to walk in a relaxed, cool manner, but I still almost stumbled over my feet.
โH-hey, Isabel,โ I greeted her in a quiet voice.
โHey, Daniel,โ she said, giving me the same shy smile.
I felt the blood rush to my face.
โSo, whatโs up?โ I started. โYou want to go back and sit with us orโฆ?โ I asked, my voice trailing off.
โNah, Iโd rather just sit with you.โ
Soon after, the two of us walked to the edge of the fairgrounds, away from the late evening bustle, and sat down between a group of trees. We just sat there, next to each other, talking about school and other mundane nonsense, holding hands.
Before long, I noticed something. Someone was stumbling down the street near us. I stared and laughed a little when I saw it was Jan. He was always quiet and distant, the last person youโd expect to party, but he was clearly drunk. At least thatโs what I thought at first. As I watched him, I noticed he wasnโt so much stumbling as walking strangely. His gait seemed wrong, his steps too wide and jerky. Then he came to an abrupt stop and just stood there. At first I didnโt know what he was doing, but another person soon joined him and then another. Before long, half a dozen teenagers had gathered around him. Now, this wasnโt too strange. During the town fair, many young people took to camping in the meadows around town to make the most out of it. Yet, as I watched them, none of them seemed to move, interact, or even talk. The strangest feeling washed over me, and for a second, I pressed down on Isabelโs hand a bit too hard.
โOuch, what are you doing?โ
โOh shit, sorry,โ I apologized, turning to her.
โAm I boring you?โ she asked.
She mustโve noticed me staring at the strange group.
โNo, of course not. Itโs just over there, that group. They are acting strange.โ
As she leaned forward to look at them, I recognized more members of the group in the bright moon light. There was Melanie, and over there were Jens and Robbie. And, as more and more teenagers joined the group, I knew who they were.
โThe mysterious fairy foresters,โ I brought out in a low voice.
โThe mysteriousโฆwhat?โ Isabel asked with an amused look on her face.
Her family had only moved to our town in the last years, so I explained the origin of the name.
โThatโs kind of cute, you know,โ she said, giggling a little.
Yet, I didnโt join in. I couldnโt. Instead, I kept watching the ever-growing group of quiet teenagers. Slowly but steadily, they all arrived. Once they had all gathered, they started on their way down the street, away from the fairgrounds and out into the night. As I watched them, that strange feeling was back. Something was wrong with them. At first I didnโt know what it was but then realized they were all moving in the same distorted way Jan had. Some of them walked in a strange jerky way, others took steps far too wide, making their bodies seem elongated. My eyes grew wide as they followed this strange procession. Before I knew what I was doing, Iโd let go of Isabelโs hand and had gotten up.
โHey, where are you going?โ she piped up.
I pointed after the strange group who were making their way down the road.
โWhy are youโ?โ
โLook at them!โ I said in a voice far too eager for my liking.
โThey are probably just camping nearby, you know, down by the lake.โ
โNo, look how they are walking! Thereโs something wrong with them, all of them. They didnโt talk orโโ
โWhy does it matter?โ
โI, I donโt know,โ I started, but by now the story Tom had told me so long ago came back to my mind and with it all those rumors and tales weโd shared about the mysterious fairy foresters.
โThey are going back,โ I pressed out.
โWhat?โ
โThey are going back to the fairy forest.โ
โWhat are you even talking about?โ she asked, annoyed by now.
โJust wait here for a bit, all right?โ
And with that, I hurried after the strange group. They were walking slowly, not in any hurry, allowing me to close the distance between us. Once I got closer, though, I couldnโt help but hide behind a tree by the road. At first I thought it was my imagination, that it was because of the clouds, but when the moonlight flooded over the group again, I couldnโt deny any more how wrong this all was. I followed them, half hidden behind the bushes at the side of the road. They didnโt notice me, or if they did, they didnโt care. Soon weโd reached the first trees of the forest, and the place where the fairy forest had been held so long ago. By now, Iโd inched closer toward the group, using the trees as cover. My eyes grew wide when I scanned the group. They had all changed and their bodies had become twisted. Some had grown in size, had become thin, elongated versions of the human body. Others seemed to have regressed in size, as if their bodies had folded into themselves. And yet others were moving on all fours and had warped into ghastly caricatures of animals. Even though it was a warm night, I felt cold, and goosebumps sprouted all over my arms. As they closed in on the forest, I noticed a figure standing between the trees. It was still a few dozen meters away, but when I strained my eyes, I saw him standing there in the moonlight. The rabbit man Tom had mentioned all those years ago.
I told myself it was a person in a rabbit costume. I tried to tell myself this entire procession was nothing but some weird act. But the longer I watched, the longer I stared at him, and the closer I got, the clearer the truth became. The face, the ears, those wide, glowing red eyes, they were real. Whatever I was seeing here and whatever that thing was, it was real, entirely real. As I stood there, hunched behind a tree, I watched as the procession of once-humans continued on past him and vanished in the forest. After the last member of the mysterious fairy foresters had vanished between the trees, the rabbit man turned in my direction. I pushed myself against the tree I was behind, but his deep red eyes still met mine. Fear washed over me and my entire body started shaking as this creature, thisโฆthing, stared at me. Its face contorted, the corners of its mouth were wandering higher and higher, twisting it into a horrible caricature of a grin. I caught my breath, held on to, no, clawed into the tree I stood behind, paralyzed by fear. I expected the creature to dash forward, to rush toward me and drag me away into the forest to where all the others had gone. Yet all it did was to give me a brief wave, bidding me to come forward. When I didnโt move, it turned and vanished between the trees. I was left alone, shaken, scared, and utterly confused about what Iโd just seen.
For long minutes, I didnโt move, scanned the forest, afraid that someone orโฆsomething would burst from it. At last, when I could move my legs again, I hurried back, away from the forest and to the fairgrounds. I stumbled around, searching for Isabel or Tom, but by now all the merriment had ended. For a moment, the shadows of the few people that remained seemed to dance and twist in front of me. I closed my eyes, took a deep breath, and when I opened them again, the illusion had vanished. All that remained were the final strugglers, stumbling around with a last drink in their hands. Before long, not sure what else to do, I went on my way home. I didnโt sleep that night. Instead, I lay in bed, wide awake, my head filled with a plethora of thoughts and scenarios. I tried to make sense of what Iโd seen, but everything I came up with was ridiculous.
The next day, the things turned from weird to outright scary. When I made my way to the fairgrounds, the police had locked the entire place down. People crowded around the area, trying to figure out what was going on. I found Tom nearby, standing between a group of other people.
โHey, whatโs going on?โ I asked, but somehow, I already knew what this was about.
โI donโt know, but I think something happened last night. Someone went missing.โ
โNot someone, the mysterious fairy foresters,โ I mumbled to myself.
Tom looked up, staring at me.
โIf any of you,โ a police officer addressed the crowd, โhave information on the whereabouts of Jan Henning, Robbie Freitag, Melanie Schuster, and Jens Seibert, please come forward.โ
As I stood there, I saw the worried faces of Janโs parents, saw Robbieโs mother crying by herself, and I subconsciously moved forward. I made my way past the crowd and went up to a policeman nearby. He escorted me to the fairโs small office and asked me what I knew. As coherently as I could, I told him what Iโd witnessed last night. The officer listened, but I could see his face growing darker the longer I went on. It was clear he didnโt believe a word of my story. He confronted me about beer and drugs, if I thought this was a joke, but I swore what Iโd seen was the truth. Eventually, he sighed and gave me a nod, sending me off.
In the end, though, as the number of missing teenagers grew and no other clues were available, the police began a search of the forest. When they made no progress, many of the townspeople volunteered to help. Our town became quiet and somber during those days. The local newspaper was filled with articles about the disappearances, and no conversation was had that didnโt center on the fate of the mysterious fairy foresters.
After three days, I finally told the entire story to Tom. At first he called me out on it being bullshit, then he got mad at me for pulling a joke like this. When I insisted it was true, though, he became scared and confused. We joined the volunteers the very next day. I donโt know why we did it. I guess it was a mixture of morbid curiosity, fear, and a strange feeling of responsibility.
For a week, we stumbled through the forest. It felt like half the town was out here with us, calling names, scanning trees, checking crevices, and searching for any hints. It was by sheer accident that Tom and I found something. In the center of a clearing, he stumbled over a small hump and fell down. He tried to get up, but his foot was stuck. When he got free, he pulled the small, half-rotten strap of a backpack from the ground. We both stared at it with wide eyes before we called out to the people nearby. Tools were brought, and under the watchful eye of the police, people started unearthing the small clearing. When the first bones were found, it was clear weโd stumbled upon a mass grave.
What was thought to be the final, heart-wrenching answer to this case would only pose more questions, questions no one could answer. The skeletal remains of about two dozen elementary school children were found in the clearing. From the remnants of clothes, backpacks, and other items found on the bodies, there was no doubt who they were. They were the bodies of all the kids who Tom had seen follow the strange rabbit man into the forest so many years ago.
And thatโs when I knew why the mysterious fairy foresters had always seemed so weird. Because those kids whoโd returned that same evening, whoโd lived amongst us for so many years, had been something entirely different.