Jennifer McMahon: A Reading Guide

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. This page contains affiliate links where I may receive a small commission at no extra cost to you.

Jennifer McMahon writes horror for people who mostly read mysteries, and that is a description rather than a criticism.

Her books are built as investigations. Somebody is missing, somebody has died, and a woman in the present starts looking into it, usually while the narrative cuts back to an earlier period where you learn things the investigator doesn’t have. The supernatural element is real, arrives late, and is generally held ambiguous for as long as the structure will bear.

She is a New York Times bestseller and almost invisible in horror circles, which is what happens when your publisher markets you as suspense. The Winter People was a Book of the Month pick and sold enormously, and a great many horror readers have never heard of her.

What the Jennifer McMahon books are genuinely good at is Vermont in winter. The isolation, the cold, the specific quality of a small New England town where everyone knows what happened and nobody says. The settings do a great deal of the work.

I haven’t read these. What follows is the critical consensus.

I write horror fiction rooted in the same tradition as the authors on this page. If you love classic horror and weird tales, you might enjoy my work, too. Sign up, and I’ll send you one of my best stories for free.
* indicates required

The Short Version

Read The Winter People. It is her best-known and her best, and it is a proper horror novel rather than a suspense one.

Then The Invited if you want the haunted house, or Promise Not to Tell if you want the one that started her.

The Essential

The Winter People (2014)

Cover of The Winter People by Jennifer McMahon
Jennifer McMahon – The Winter People

West Hall, Vermont. In 1908 Sara Harrison Shea is found dead in a field behind her house, months after her daughter died, and her diary survives. In the present, a nineteen-year-old and her younger sister are searching for their mother, who has vanished from the same house.

The device at the center is the reason it works. Sara’s diary lays out a method for bringing the dead back for seven days, learned from a woman in the woods, and the novel is very clear that those seven days are no gift.

The 1908 sections are considerably stronger than the present-day ones, which is a recurring pattern in her work, and the sleepers are one of the better inventions in recent horror.

Also on ghost books and folk horror.


The Invited (2019)

Cover of The Invited by Jennifer McMahon
Jennifer McMahon – The Invited

A couple leave teaching jobs in Connecticut to build a house on a plot of land in rural Vermont, and the plot has a history involving a woman hanged as a witch in 1924.

The building is the structure. Helen sources materials from local sites connected to the dead woman, a beam from one place, a mantel from another, and each object brings something with it, so the house is assembled out of the haunting rather than merely containing it.

That idea is the best thing McMahon has done, and most readers who find the book agree it deserved far more attention than it got.

Also on haunted house books.


The Rest

Promise Not to Tell (2007)

Cover of Promise Not to Tell by Jennifer McMahon
Jennifer McMahon – Promise Not to Tell

Kate Cypher comes back to rural Vermont to look after her mother, who has Alzheimer’s, and arrives on the night a girl is murdered in the same manner as her childhood friend Del Griffin thirty-one years earlier.

Del was the Potato Girl, the daughter of a dirt-poor farming family, and she smelled and she was tormented for it, and Kate was her friend in private and joined in with the others in public.

That’s the actual subject, and McMahon never lets Kate off. The novel is about a woman who has spent three decades not thinking about what she did at eleven, and the guilt is more present than the ghost.

The 1971 sections and the commune Kate’s mother lived in are the strongest material.

It was her first novel under her own name, it hit the New York Times list, and the pattern for everything after is already fully formed in it.


The One I Left Behind (2013) and Island of Lost Girls (2008)

Cover of The One I Left Behind by Jennifer McMahon
Jennifer McMahon – The One I Left Behind

Two from the middle of the run and both are closer to crime fiction than to horror.

The One I Left Behind alternates between 1985, when a killer called Neptune left severed hands on the police station steps, and 2010, when Reggie’s mother, who was Neptune’s only surviving victim and who disappeared twenty-five years ago, walks into a homeless shelter alive.

The mother is the reason it works. She was an alcoholic and a bad parent before any of it, and Reggie’s relief and resentment are equally weighted.

Island of Lost Girls opens with a woman watching a rabbit in a costume abduct a child from a gas station, and it goes back to a childhood friendship and a disappearance a decade earlier.

Both are competently done. Neither has a supernatural element, and both are the books McMahon readers name least.


The Night Sister (2015) and Burntown (2017)

Cover of The Night Sister by Jennifer McMahon
Jennifer McMahon – The Night Sister

Two of the stranger ones and The Night Sister is the better.

The Night Sister is set at the Tower Motel in Vermont, a failing roadside place with a novelty tower, across three timelines: two sisters in 1959, their daughters in 1989, and the present, after one of them kills her family. The folklore is the mare, a shapeshifter from Eastern European belief, and the 1959 material about two girls and a secret is the best writing in it.

Burntown is the most ambitious thing she has attempted and the least successful. A machine invented by Thomas Edison to speak to the dead, a flooded Vermont city, a homeless community, and a drug that shows the future.

The common verdict on Burntown is too many threads, and an invention that deserved a tighter book.

Both are worth reading after the top four.


The Drowning Kind (2021) and My Darling Girl (2023)

Cover of The Drowning Kind by Jennifer McMahon
Jennifer McMahon – The Drowning Kind

The two most recent and both return to what she does best.

The Drowning Kind is a spring-fed pool at a Vermont hotel that grants what people ask for and takes something in exchange, told across 1929 and the present. Jax comes home after her sister drowns in it. The 1929 timeline follows a woman whose husband brought her there to recover.

The water is the best thing McMahon has written. It’s cold, it’s bottomless, and the exchange is never negotiable.

My Darling Girl is a possession story about a woman whose estranged alcoholic mother comes to stay while dying of cancer, and it is her nastiest book. The mother was genuinely abusive, the daughter has forgiven nothing, and what is in her is using all of it.

Readers tend to shelve The Drowning Kind with her best and to find My Darling Girl more uneven.

Also on possession books.


Where to Start

Read The Winter People, and pay attention to the 1908 chapters, which are where the book lives.

If it works, read The Invited, which has the best single idea in the Jennifer McMahon books.

My Darling Girl if you want the hardest one. Promise Not to Tell if you want to see the formula arrive fully formed.

And go in expecting a mystery structure with a supernatural payload, because that’s consistently the shape, and that’s why horror readers keep missing her.

My best horror books list ranks the rest of the genre. The Vermont hauntings sit close to my folk horror list.


More in Horror

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

READ MY BOOKS


Cover of New Haven


Cover of Fuck Monsters


Cover of Miller's Academy


Cover of The Jenson Boardinghouse


Cover of The First Few Times Always Hurt


Cover of Irradiant Tears


Cover of Unsettling Truth
Ethereal Writing participates in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn commissions by linking to Amazon. This simply means that whenever you buy a book on Amazon from a link on here, I get a small percentage of its price. With that you help support Ethereal Writing and it is very much appreciated.